PaperClipAI/tests/runner-e2e/SECURITY.md

# Runner E2E security for a public repository

## Attended connection authentication

See [PROVIDER-CONNECTIONS.md](PROVIDER-CONNECTIONS.md) for the explicit-only
`provider-connections` suite, local/staging target ownership, dedicated browser
profiles, credential handoffs, private evidence, and cleanup contract.

Provider-connection results may retain closed diagnostic codes and terminal run
status before managed-instance teardown. Only error records and failed tool
receipts are inspected; raw error messages, child stderr, model output and
reasoning are not retained. Unknown causes and unavailable logs stay explicit.
The optional installed-Gemini filesystem smoke uses synthetic credentials and
loopback model responses, makes no real provider calls, and removes its
disposable home/workspace.

The explicit [public MCP suite](PUBLIC-MCP.md) also creates a disposable browser
account and OAuth grant. Signup and token exchange use Node fetch, credentials
stay outside model context, and dynamic cookie/code/token values join the
attempt's redaction set. Tracing, video and automatic screenshots are disabled
for that suite; only reviewed fixture task routes may produce public screenshots.
External API evidence retains visible answers and tool outcomes, never raw model
reasoning. Empty provider configuration directories prevent operator plugins and
MCP credentials from being inherited. All grants are revoked during cleanup and
the launcher removes the isolated database and provider homes.

This suite can spend provider money, expose selected local and workflow API credentials to isolated
test processes, publish a container, retain private visual evidence, and write
public structured evidence. Treat changes to the workflow, harness, fixture
prompts, evidence packager, and publisher as security-sensitive production
changes.

## GitHub authorization

Set `RUNNER_E2E_ALLOWED_ACTOR_IDS` to a non-empty JSON array of numeric GitHub
user IDs. Keep the list equal to the owners of `.github/**` in
`.github/CODEOWNERS`. For example, use `[123456,789012]`. Resolve each ID from
the authenticated CLI and verify the login before adding it:

```bash
gh api users/LOGIN --jq '{login,id}'
```

The paid workflows reject manual dispatches when the workflow definition does
not come from the default branch. A trusted dispatcher may name any branch in
`paperclipai/paperclip` as the code under test. The authorization job resolves
that branch through the GitHub API and passes only its immutable commit SHA to a
credential-free target-lock job. That job checks out the commit, regenerates
`pnpm-lock.yaml` once with lifecycle scripts disabled and lockfile-only mode,
then uploads the file under a run-attempt-scoped artifact ID. Catalog, image,
shared-build, provider-pack, and paid test jobs download that exact artifact by
ID, verify its recorded SHA-256, and restore it before setup or a frozen
dependency install. The lock resolver receives no provider credentials and
must never run repository lifecycle scripts. The shared-build and provider-pack
jobs also receive no provider credentials and disable dependency lifecycle
scripts; they package outputs with SHA-256 sidecars that consumers verify
before extraction. The paid test job installs with lifecycle scripts disabled,
and materializes the exact pinned OpenCode executable from its lockfile-verified
optional package without invoking package lifecycle code. Provider secrets are
scoped only to the final test step rather than dependency setup. Report sanitization and AWS
history publication explicitly use the trusted workflow commit and do not
consume the target lockfile. Never run the workflow definition from the target
branch.

The workflows verify both the original actor and triggering actor for every
scheduled or manual attempt, including human reruns. Every
secret-bearing job repeats this check as its first step so GitHub's partial-job
rerun feature cannot bypass a successful predecessor authorization job. The
legacy manually dispatched E2E workflow uses the same gate. Numeric IDs are
stable across username changes and prevent lookalike-name authorization.

The full-stack and live campaigns have one Sunday UTC schedule each and also
support explicit manual dispatch. Their legacy-named nightly repository
variables remain independent kill switches. Neither paid workflow accepts
pull-request, push, workflow-run, or reusable-workflow triggers.

Protect the default branch, require review for workflow/harness paths, restrict
workflow dispatch permission, and restrict repository variable/environment
administration to the same trusted maintainers. Configure the organization to
allow only approved GitHub Actions. A malicious change merged into the default
branch executes with the same authority as the suite.

Every external action in the paid workflow is pinned to a full commit SHA. Keep
the adjacent major-version comment for update tooling, and resolve and review a
new immutable SHA before upgrading an action. The credential-free security test
rejects mutable tag or branch references.

## Secrets and protected environments

Explicit Grok subscription campaigns may select `GROK_AUTH_JSON` from the same
protected paid environment. Deliver it only to that subscription profile's paid
test step. Prefer a dedicated test-account login and refresh it before a campaign.
The fixture stores only the selected login in its disposable company home, rejects
ambient/redirected homes, and removes the login during teardown. Token fragments
and account identifiers inside its JSON join the evidence redaction set. The
subscription suite remains manual-only and never falls back to `XAI_API_KEY`.

Create `runner-e2e-paid`, restrict deployments to the default branch, and put
only `OPENAI_API_KEY`, `ANTHROPIC_API_KEY`, `OPENROUTER_API_KEY`, `XAI_API_KEY`, and
`DAYTONA_API_KEY` in it. `KIMI_MODEL_API_KEY` remains a local-only catalog name
for pending explicit profiles and is intentionally absent from the workflow
environment. Product E2E pending-profile admission remains gated separately.
Do not duplicate these credentials as repository- or
organization-level Actions secrets: environment scoping is the boundary that
prevents branch or pull-request jobs from requesting them. Require approval
from an account in `RUNNER_E2E_ALLOWED_ACTOR_IDS` for this environment and
disable administrator bypass. The authorize, target-lock, catalog, image,
report, history, and Pages jobs receive none of these secrets.
Each full-stack matrix cell receives only its selected profile credential, plus
Daytona only for Daytona cells. Secret-bearing and OIDC jobs use frozen installs
without a shared dependency cache.
On disposable GitHub Linux runners with Ubuntu's unprivileged-user-namespace
restriction, the authorized default-branch workflow provisions an AppArmor profile before provider credentials are exposed. The profile is attached to the exact
lockfile-pinned Codex executable. It grants `userns` so Codex can construct its
filesystem sandbox; it does not disable the kernel restriction or Codex's
workspace policy. Setup fails before invoking a model if the noninteractive
profile load fails. Target-controlled tests only probe the existing sandbox and never invoke sudo or load host policy. This host-only profile disappears with the ephemeral runner.
See [Ubuntu's namespace restriction documentation](https://documentation.ubuntu.com/security/security-features/privilege-restriction/apparmor/).
Local developer machines are never modified by this setup. Legacy Codex fixtures
disable optional shell-environment snapshots to avoid persisting credentials;
other suites retain the persisted-state scanner. The `first-task` suite omits
private home/workspace credential-persistence scanning so its evaluation focuses
on onboarding behavior. Artifact redaction and publication scanning remain in
force for every suite.
The Paperclip server process also receives none; the browser posts each value
once to the encrypted company secret API and agents/environments retain only
secret references.

The explicit managed first-task cell observes the wizard's two owned setup
responses only to correlate their exact lease IDs with same-company environment
records. Raw probe/setup responses, account references, opaque provider lease
identities and setup screenshots remain private. Public first-task evidence
continues through the existing projection. Missing or foreign lease identities
cannot acquire attribution or a zero-cost estimate; incomplete setup coverage
stays unavailable even if later task-run billing succeeds. Platform qualification
uses the existing permission-gated environment probe, without granting new
permissions or accepting fixture-authored qualification metadata.

The context-integrity catalog lists six pending Kimi/Grok cells for discovery:
two cases each across `legacy-kimi-cli`, `legacy-kimi-acp`, and `legacy-grok`.
The launcher and direct Playwright runner reject these profiles before loading
credentials. Pi has no qualified model source and is not cataloged. Admission
remains blocked until identity, authentication, skills, session, and billing
evidence is qualified together.

Create `runner-e2e-history`, also default-branch-only, for the OIDC publishing
job. It contains no long-lived AWS key. Required reviewers may be added when a
human approval on every nightly publication is acceptable; otherwise rely on
the actor gate, environment branch restriction, and protected default branch.

## Runner fleet isolation

When `RUNNER_E2E_AWS_ENABLED=true`, paid matrix cells, reusable runner builds,
and Daytona image builds use the exact RunsOn fleet
selector `runs-on/fleet=paperclip-public-pr-x64/env=public-ci`, matching the AWS
fleet selected by `pr-trusted.yml` only after its stable numeric-ID trust gate.
Any other or missing toggle value falls back to the GitHub-hosted
`ubuntu-latest` runner and its lower concurrency ceiling. The workflow chooses
between those two reviewed literal labels; it never evaluates a configured
runner label.

Daytona image builds depend on successful campaign authorization and keep the
existing GHCR publication and signing permissions. They receive no provider
credentials and do not enter the `runner-e2e-paid` environment.

Keep both runner targets restricted to `paperclipai/paperclip` and workflows
that independently authorize trusted source revisions. Never let a fork or
untrusted pull-request workflow target them. The RunsOn fleet must launch a
fresh ephemeral instance for every job, prohibit persistent runner reuse, and
disable interactive SSH/debug access unless a separate incident procedure
explicitly authorizes it.

Changing the runner does not widen who can authorize secret access. The paid
workflow still has only schedule and manual triggers, requires its trusted
definition to come from the protected default branch, requires allowlisted
stable actor IDs before checkout, and repeats that authorization as the first
matrix step. Provider credentials come only from the protected
`runner-e2e-paid` environment. The fleet selector is an exact workflow literal;
the only repository-controlled routing input is its boolean rollout switch, so
configuration cannot redirect a secret-bearing job to an arbitrary runner.

The optional target branch is code, not workflow authority. A CODEOWNER who
dispatches a target branch explicitly authorizes that branch's selected test
process to receive the cell's scoped provider credential. The workflow resolves
the target only inside the same repository, pins one SHA for the campaign, and
checks it out only after authorization. Target-controlled code cannot replace
the report sanitizer or the AWS history publisher. Fork refs and
target-controlled workflow definitions do not enter this path.

## AWS OIDC and S3

The AWS role trust policy should accept only GitHub's OIDC audience and the
publishing environment subject:

```json
{
  "Version": "2012-10-17",
  "Statement": [
    {
      "Effect": "Allow",
      "Principal": {
        "Federated": "arn:aws:iam::ACCOUNT_ID:oidc-provider/token.actions.githubusercontent.com"
      },
      "Action": "sts:AssumeRoleWithWebIdentity",
      "Condition": {
        "StringEquals": {
          "token.actions.githubusercontent.com:aud": "sts.amazonaws.com",
          "token.actions.githubusercontent.com:sub": "repo:paperclipai/paperclip:environment:runner-e2e-history"
        }
      }
    }
  ]
}
```

Grant only List on the bucket prefix and Get/Put on its objects. Do not grant
Delete, ACL, bucket-policy, or wildcard-resource permissions:

```json
{
  "Version": "2012-10-17",
  "Statement": [
    {
      "Effect": "Allow",
      "Action": "s3:ListBucket",
      "Resource": "arn:aws:s3:::BUCKET",
      "Condition": {
        "StringLike": { "s3:prefix": ["runner-e2e", "runner-e2e/*"] }
      }
    },
    {
      "Effect": "Allow",
      "Action": ["s3:GetObject", "s3:PutObject"],
      "Resource": "arn:aws:s3:::BUCKET/runner-e2e/*"
    }
  ]
}
```

Enable S3 versioning, default encryption, and Block Public Access. Disable
object ACLs. CloudFront receives read-only access through Origin Access Control;
the bucket itself stays private. Log S3 data writes and alert on attempts to
write outside the prefix or assume the role with a different subject.

Campaign prefixes are content-digested and immutable. The publisher refuses a
different digest at an existing campaign key. Only the compact history and
latest pointers are mutable, and S3 versioning makes those updates recoverable.

## Public evidence boundary

CloudFront and GitHub Pages are public. Fixture identifiers, timing, token
usage, costs, normalized results, and trusted runner PNG screenshots are
expected public data. Each
public screenshot must carry the explicit `public-runner-fixture` marker in
the normalized result. This includes a `failure.png` capture. Screenshot paths
must be safe PNG basenames and must be tied to the exact normalized execution
ID and attempt. The runner capture helper accepts only the exact issue route
for the live fixture that the harness created. Other issue routes, credential
pages, setup pages, and administration pages fail closed. The
CloudFront-backed S3 history also publishes one
synthetic campaign-summary PNG generated by trusted publisher code solely from
fixed catalog labels and sanitized numeric/status fields. Video, archives,
generated Playwright/blob/HTML report trees, SVG or other active content,
credentials, Paperclip homes, databases, workspaces, master keys,
raw/unredacted logs, unmarked images, and unallowlisted files are not public.
Per-attempt JSON snapshots, result copies, logs, Markdown, and text files stay
in the retained Actions artifact. Credential redaction does not remove hidden
reasoning or provider session identities, so a text extension never admits a
file to the public bundle. Graded results remain in `normalized-results.json`.

The packaged evidence uploaded as a 30-day GitHub Actions artifact has a
different, broader boundary. Text is exact-value and key-shape scanned and
redacted. PNG and WebM are raw-byte scanned; SVG is rejected during packaging
because it is active content. Raster pixels cannot be exhaustively
secret-scanned by bytes, so fixture authors must treat every marked capture as
public and must never extend the allowed task route to credentials, secrets,
private user data, or other non-public content. Adding or changing a marked
capture requires review of the visible page state. Videos remain
access-controlled.

Before permanent publication, the campaign publisher creates a separate S3
stage and retains only result PNGs with the explicit `public-runner-fixture`
marker under `evidence/`. This applies even to malformed JSON and renamed
process logs. Original packaged evidence and grades remain unchanged.
It then launches publisher-only Chromium with networking blocked to render one
`public-images/campaign-summary.png`. That fixed-path PNG is capped at 12 MiB
and its signature is validated. Per-attempt XML is excluded because browsers
can process XML/XSLT;
the only public XML is the root `junit.xml`, which the report aggregator
constructs from fixed markup and XML-escaped fields. Videos, archives,
raw/unallowlisted logs, SVG, undeclared images, generated reports, and symlinks
fail closed or are removed before the immutable manifest is calculated.

GitHub Pages is built from a second stage without the synthetic summary PNG but
with the same trusted-fixture screenshot allowlist. A leak detected by the
existing packager scan fails the cell and withholds the unsafe file.

Rotate the affected credential immediately if a secret-scanning failure or
unexpected public object is observed. Preserve the access-controlled Actions
artifact and S3 object versions for incident analysis; do not weaken scanning
to make a campaign publish.

`agent-chat-qualification.worker-crash-retry` is local-only and explicit-only.
Linux with Python pidfd support is required; unsupported hosts fail before signalling.
The fault target comes from the public run detail, must be native and running,
and must have an exact `--run-id` command argument. PID 1, the harness PID,
noninteger PIDs, remote profiles, and mismatched identities are refused. The
fixture workspace must be within the disposable instance root. The helper pins an owned pidfd, verifies the exact run argument and recorded
process start ticks again after evidence capture, and signals through that handle.
PID reuse cannot redirect the signal. This is one
specific process signal, never a name-based or machine-wide process kill.
The bounded fixture command is released even on failure; normal instance cleanup
still owns all disposable processes and files. No credentials enter the prompt,
fault metadata, or structured grading fixtures.

### Candidate ACP qualification

The explicit-only `extended-harnesses` launcher removes ambient candidate
admission, then authorizes only selected candidate/model pairs in its isolated
server process. The server never reads admission from agent configuration,
resolved credential bindings, or provider environment. Invalid, duplicate and
mismatched authorization fails closed. Verified packaging and normal company
and tool governance still apply. `CURSOR_AUTH_TOKEN` and
`COPILOT_GITHUB_TOKEN` enter via encrypted company secret references, and all
Cursor, Copilot, GitHub and GH environment variables are stripped from the
server environment. GitHub PAT shapes are included in retained-evidence scans.
Candidates have no automatic infrastructure retries; spending must be reconciled
before a deliberate repeat.

Copilot protection fixtures use production browser/public API permission and
cancellation paths. Their local one-shot socket accepts a nonce/PID only and owns
one fixed bounded child; it cannot select commands, arguments, or paths. The exact
native client command is supplied by the fixture, while production notices retain
only its SHA-256. The fixture keeps private process identities local, closes its
owned socket/child in cleanup, and never signals API-reported PIDs. Directory
watch loss makes the denial oracle incomplete; it must not become a no-effect pass.

Pi Daytona controls bind process identity to the independent Linux observer's
PID, start ticks and boot ID within the exact admitted run/lease/sandbox. The
controller's `processStartedAt` annotations may change as launch metadata settles
and do not identify a remote process birth. Every remote snapshot and retirement
seal must retain the original birth identity and complete no-effect journal.
Local controls retain their separate public process-authority comparison.

Pi provider-death admission accepts the native bootstrap's `/proc/self/fd/3`
or `/proc/self/fd/7` wrapper launch only after binding that held descriptor and
the wrapper executable to the sealed snapshot Node inode. Exact guard and
entrypoint paths, closure hashes, Pi title, run/lease ancestry and fresh process
birth checks remain required. Other descriptor aliases, missing descriptors and
foreign inodes fail before any signal. Native Linux calibration exercises both
descriptor launches with synthetic owned processes and no provider credentials;
it does not qualify paid Pi behavior or change previous failed grades.

The private resource-admission marker and raw cleanup results control recovery-state retention independently of evidence packaging. A worker crash after admission keeps the owner-only recovery database; a confirmed pre-allocation bootstrap failure does not. Neither the marker nor the database enters published evidence.

## Task workspace fixture source

The explicit task-workspaces cells fetch the existing public octocat/Hello-World
repository through normal anonymous repository preparation. They do not clone the
Paperclip checkout, copy its Git credentials, create remote repositories or push.
The agent's synthetic commit remains in the disposable task workspace. Independent
Git reads validate that workspace's canonical path is inside the isolated instance
before examining history. The existing credential redactor, private evidence
packager and task-only screenshot allowlist remain authoritative. Each cell has a
single attempt, three requested turns and company/agent budget hard stops.