mirror of
https://github.com/paperclipai/paperclip.git
synced 2026-11-01 15:35:12 +01:00
DottaandPaperclip
45a3a92e6d
## Thinking Path > - Paperclip manages companies and the agents that do their work. > - Remote execution creates provider resources that need a durable owner. > - The server could create a sandbox before it saved its lease. > - A failed lease write could leave cleanup data only on the old web server disk. > - This change saves a company-scoped operation before creation and transfers ownership atomically. > - Recovery finds the original Daytona resource or records an explicit manual reconciliation outcome. ## Linked Issues or Issue Description **What happened?** A sandbox could exist without a lease after a database failure or company rebind. Failed cleanup recording could then create a local fallback file. Replacing that web server could lose the cleanup reference. **Expected behavior** A failed admission write makes no provider call. An interrupted creation retains a committed operation. Recovery must not create a second sandbox or destroy an attached lease. **Steps to reproduce** 1. Run the disposable PostgreSQL cases in `server/src/__tests__/sandbox-creation-operations.test.ts`. 2. Reject the lease insert after the controlled provider creates its resource. 3. Start a new receiver process with a different empty web disk. It must find the same resource and create one cleanup owner. Related ownership report: Refs #14672. This change addresses new allocations before lease persistence. It does not replace existing lease recovery. ## What Changed - Add an idempotent migration and a small creation-operation table. Retain original company, environment and run identities across deletion. - Commit creation intent before run, ad-hoc lease, and plugin task replacement calls. Fence duplicate requests and ambiguous lease commits. - Retain a known returned task resource ID in the existing operation before attachment. Preserve manual reconciliation and never delete an ambiguously attached resource. - Keep company and run authority checks and atomic lease transfer with the lease owner. - Reuse Daytona names, labels, read-only inspection and claimed cleanup. Keep provider payload handling in the provider. - Retain nonsecret credential identity hashes. Refuse recovery lookup under a changed credential value. - Record manual reconciliation for missing/deleted or explicitly inactive saved credentials, versions, and provider vaults. Keep temporary resolution failures retryable. Never reactivate a disabled credential. - Use transaction signals and concrete deadlines. Failed records back off independently. Manual reconciliation stays durable and quiet. - Remove new orphan-file fallback writes from the covered paths. Keep legacy file replay and its tests for cutover. - Replace obsolete fallback-producer assertions with normal-entrypoint durability tests. Keep cleanup, diagnostics and warm handoff coverage. ## Verification - [Independent current-head verification](https://github.com/paperclipai/paperclip/pull/18357#issuecomment-6534744320) passed 190/190 combined tests, 40/40 incoming TestOps tests, full workspace typecheck, and build. PR head `958af986130f25e136065ad30d1fdd843c46255c` has tree `e6c3e5b02182d5941a70ccf5bf55638df3c2e28d`, identical to tested combined commit `b9d7a9c2e9b30f0153685fb24a5f70b56132201f`. Real PostgreSQL, compiled Rust Runner and controlled object providers were used; external-S3 integration remains outside this local proof. - Current head `958af986130f25e136065ad30d1fdd843c46255c` normally merges master `8595efc20bda3ce20a9fbbf34a5d156a6fcf6d57`. The sole conflict was the maintenance test: a parameterized case now preserves both legacy-local `local_storage` and valid shared-S3 `provider_mismatch` checks, including the parent local receipt, exact version identity, missing-snapshot/no-seed refusal, and unchanged persisted row. The three master TestOps files remain intact. No production, schema, migration, or package changes were made after the fully qualified prior head `0b4d05505e`. Independent review approved the resolution; the full managed-skill-content file and Cloud guard controls pass 58/58 (105.11 seconds). [Required PR CI passed on this exact merge head, first attempt](https://github.com/paperclipai/paperclip/actions/runs/41136987412): 54 successful checks and three intended skips. The additional Paperclip review is neutral at 4/5; two external Superagent checks (Contributor trust and Security Scan) remain in progress with zero annotations and no assessment, so they are not passing scan evidence. Greptile reviewed exact head `958af986130f25e136065ad30d1fdd843c46255c` at 5/5; the final thread audit has zero unresolved threads. All completed evidence below retains its recorded revision scope. The additional Paperclip Review on `958af98613` is neutral at 4/5 with a Ship verdict and no must-fix or should-fix item. Its optional observation is that a generic create rejection remains pending/manual even when an operator believes allocation did not occur. This change preserves uncertainty because the generic create-error contract does not prove provider absence; no new error classification or provider-specific compensation was added. - [Independent final-source verification](https://github.com/paperclipai/paperclip/pull/18357#issuecomment-6534328247) passed all 189 real-PostgreSQL/Runner and controlled-fixture cases, full workspace typecheck, and build. The integration commit `c8411a8528386f4824b340ec5fdaaed1efb9ea69` has the same source tree as final PR head `0b4d05505e` (tree `bda65efc14b4c904d0f589154db77bb160641c8c`). Controlled object-provider coverage passed; the separately guarded external-S3 suite was not run because the bounded local MinIO pull was unavailable. This includes the two final compatibility fixes. - The first final-head CI attempt exposed one E2E timing failure in `disconnect-write-recovery.spec.ts:181`: the title stayed unchanged through the 15-second session-recovery poll. The same original case passed in 13.8 seconds on immediately prior head `7ec06f77b7`, and all UI/session/E2E source is identical across those heads. The failure log and CI artifacts are retained; no cause is claimed. One failed-job-only retry is authorized on this evidence, without changing a timeout, assertion, or production behavior. [The single failed-job retry completed successfully](https://github.com/paperclipai/paperclip/actions/runs/41133619710/attempts/2): all 35 E2E shard cases passed (6.6 minutes), including the original session-recovery case in 14.0 seconds. The initial failure remains disclosed and its cause remains unproven. - Final head `0b4d05505ee0aa72f2981cdff74761406960ec73` adds two independently reviewed integration fixes after the complete 7ec CI matrix exposed two deterministic failures. Server 9/12 failed legacy local-storage maintenance because the CLI reached the new Cloud server startup guard; server 5/12 found the Daytona package version did not match its bumped manifest. The failed run is retained at https://github.com/paperclipai/paperclip/actions/runs/41131204203. It is not passing evidence and was not blindly retried. - Maintenance now constructs the existing explicit storage dependency after loading the required persisted Cloud snapshot, and passes it to both maintenance owners. It can verify legacy local storage before provider cutover while normal Cloud server startup remains guarded. The original case reproduced red locally, then the complete managed-skill-content and managed-cloud-prerequisites files passed 57/57 (32.05 seconds), including missing-snapshot refusal, unchanged stored configuration, and existing server guard controls. Daytona package version now matches manifest 0.1.10; the complete bundled package identity file passed 14/14 (3.98 seconds), and explicit manifest/lifecycle controls passed 2/2 (328 intentionally filtered; 3.42 seconds). An initial workspace-filter command matched no project and is not counted as pass evidence. The final diff changes no sandbox runtime or schema behavior. [Full CI is green on this exact final head](https://github.com/paperclipai/paperclip/actions/runs/41133619710/attempts/2): 56 successful checks, three intended skips, one additional incomplete/neutral Paperclip Review, and no pending or failed checks. The neutral review is not a passing assessment. [Greptile reviewed the exact final head at 5/5](https://github.com/paperclipai/paperclip/pull/18357#issuecomment-6529396969), with no new actionable issues and all review threads resolved. - Final combined head `7ec06f77b7c14a745c569d18401f16df3d26b626` includes master managed-skills migration 0417 and shared-storage prerequisites from `198218bf55` through normal merges. Sandbox creation moves to generated `0418_curved_lady_mastermind.sql`; its idempotent SQL is byte-for-byte unchanged. The regenerated 0418 snapshot contains both sandbox creation operations and the master skill mutation receipts, and points to the master 0417 snapshot. Master SQL and journal history remain intact. Exactly five snapshots remain, 0414 through 0418. The only sandbox-specific changes since the approved credential policy are migration metadata/number and the matching test/document references; the sandbox runtime files are unchanged. - [Independent final combined verification](https://github.com/paperclipai/paperclip/pull/18357#issuecomment-6533960026) passed on integration revision `e6f05b4cf0cd`, containing final sandbox head `7ec06f77b7` and actual master `198218bf55`: migration/declaration checks, all 158 real-PostgreSQL/Runner and controlled-fixture cases (251 seconds), full workspace typecheck (81 seconds), and build (35 seconds). - Final combined migration proof: fresh real PostgreSQL has both tables. A separate original-0417 sandbox table with a retained pending row survives two applications of the renamed 0418 SQL unchanged, with the expected primary/index and foreign-key structure. Migration numbering/safety checks pass. The normal runtime migration reapply case passes 1/1 (20 intentionally filtered cases; 46.69 seconds). The first temporary qualification harness stopped before any database assertion because its external `.ts` file selected CommonJS; the `.mts` harness corrected that setup and passed. Independent review approved the exact metadata and reference diff. Earlier full suite and live-provider results below retain their stated revision scope. - Credential-policy head `c606d473b03709f27577a55a1dfc0b0d3b4359fd` handles the remaining inactive-credential review warning. The existing boundary accepts only concrete secret-owner 422 codes and exact no-details disabled/coming-soon vault messages. Unknown 422, authorization errors, provider wrappers, and temporary database/provider failures still propagate. Independent source review approved this three-file correction. No generic resolver, schema, provider protocol, retry cap, or activation behavior changed. - Creation/cleanup qualification at `c606d473b0`: all 39 cases pass against real PostgreSQL (81.27 seconds). The new cases use actual disabled/archived saved secrets, a valid disabled version, and provider vaults created ready before normal API updates disable them or mark them coming soon. Each remains manual through restart/repeated scans, with zero provider lookup and no retry deadline. The independent plugin idle blocker remains intact. The temporary 503 control retains retry ownership and later recovers one cleanup owner. Before this correction, all five inactive-state cases remained pending; that failed evidence is retained. The prior 18-case known-ID task proof below belongs to `237144fcf6`, whose helper and task path are unchanged by this correction. - Known-ID head `237144fcf69a249c0e0310563428c0f55ed6d55c` also addresses the independent task-replacement reliability warning. The existing creation operation now saves only the known nonsecret returned resource ID before expiry validation and attachment. The write is scoped to operation/company/original environment and allows only a missing or matching ID. It changes no ownership state and copies no resolved configuration, credentials, or provider payload. Independent source review approved this four-file fix. - The complete real-PostgreSQL task suite passes 18/18 (9.52 seconds). Rejected attachments retain the ID through manual reconciliation and repeated scans. A real committed attachment followed by an injected lost response retains the same active lease and attached operation, with no release or second create. Same-ID retries work; conflicting IDs and foreign companies cannot change it. The initial three regression cases failed because the ID was absent, before the fix. - The shipped Daytona manifest does not declare task support, so it cannot enter this generic replacement path. The dispatcher requires both declared task support and an environmentTask worker method. Generic drivers without creation lookup still use manual reconciliation, with a known returned ID retained when the database write can commit. No automatic lookup capability or unconditional compensation was added. - Previous boundary-fix head `8ba77def151ea85eeae2db7693254db7f87673b0` fixes the fresh review finding about missing credentials. Only known secret-owner 404 results at the recovery secret-resolution boundary select the existing manual outcome. Provider inspection and transient database/provider errors remain retryable. Independent source review approved this change. - Secret-boundary focused acceptance at `8ba77def15`: all 34 cases pass against isolated real PostgreSQL. The complete creation suite passes 16/16 (100.75 seconds); the complete cleanup coordinator suite passes 18/18 (99.83 seconds). The new cases use normal saved-secret creation and deletion, confirm zero provider lookup, restart/repeated scans, no automatic deadline, preserved independent plugin idle blocking, and no additional idle blocker after the controlled worker supplies its quiet proof. A temporary 503 resolution failure preserves pending ownership and later recovers one cleanup owner. No additional live provider resource was created. - Failed attempts remain part of the evidence. The initial red run reproduced the pending-operation bug and also exposed a numeric-deadline test harness mistake, which was corrected. A later combined run reported an existing replacement-receiver failure and a new idle-fixture assertion failure; it was interrupted while the next test file remained in imports. An isolated diagnostic confirmed that the manual state was correct but the installed fixture plugin correctly blocked sleep without its independent quiet proof. The corrected test retains that blocker assertion before supplying the controlled worker witness. The unchanged replacement-receiver case passes in the final complete 16-case run; its earlier failure is not counted as a pass or assigned a proven cause. No timeout or production idle guard was relaxed. - Greptile reviewed previous combined head `7ec06f77b7c14a745c569d18401f16df3d26b626` at 5/5, with no unresolved review threads. Its CI produced the two concrete integration failures addressed above. The earlier CI and live evidence below remain historical evidence, not a claim that the current full gates have completed. - Master integration update: merged `dbff3747b8` and then latest master `76fde891cc` without rewriting branch history. Only `doc/DATABASE.md` conflicted; the sandbox ownership, object-backed run evidence, and cloud configuration sections all remain. The master merges changed no sandbox implementation, migration, or provider code. Migration numbering/safety checks pass and exactly five schema snapshots remain. At merge head `f5d23d4a59828835d01c150f83fa2645fb2d3bec`, the two focused creation/coordinator suites pass all 32 cases against isolated real PostgreSQL (64.57 seconds). Those merge-head checks precede the missing-credential fix below. The earlier live Daytona proof still covers the unchanged normal creation/lookup/teardown path; the new missing-credential branch is qualified with real PostgreSQL and controlled provider hooks. The optional Superagent Security Scan was inconclusive on prior head `7ec06f77b7`: its pinned PR merge-base checkout failed or timed out, with a neutral conclusion and zero annotations. An earlier scan could not start within 120 seconds; a bounded rerun request returned HTTP 404. These scanner failures are not passing security-scan evidence. On final head `0b4d05505e`, the additional Paperclip Review check is neutral: its assigned review execution did not complete and produced no validated assessment. Fresh Greptile 5/5 and independent source review are separate evidence. Previous-head required CI, independent review, and the live Daytona qualification below passed. - [Complete previous-head CI](https://github.com/paperclipai/paperclip/actions/runs/41105726052) passed at `0b5cbb763ab8faa25aa0ff1d8a405cdc0d3db409`: 53 successful checks and three intended skips, including typecheck, full tests, build and E2E. Greptile is 5/5 on this head and both original findings are resolved. - Initial head: 200 PostgreSQL runtime, creation and coordinator tests passed. The corrected head also passes all 32 creation and coordinator tests, including deletion before/during lookup, a failed lookup after deletion, restart, settled polling and actual idle-safety checks. Cases cover failed admission, failed lease writes, concurrent recovery, lost provider replies, ambiguous transfer retries, company rebind, environment deletion, stopped runs, lookup backoff, restart, drain and settled SQL quiet. - Separate receiver processes: passed. A controlled HTTP provider retains the resource while three independent receiver processes use two empty web disks. Recovery creates one cleanup owner and never repeats creation. - Fresh PostgreSQL migration and two additional applications: passed. The pending creation row survives unchanged. - Server TypeScript and SDK/shared build checks pass after the corrections. Migration numbering/safety checks passed. Exactly five schema snapshots remain. - Daytona adapter: all 330 tests passed, including stable-name lookup, ownership checks, deletion and the updated manifest version. An earlier run exposed the version expectation and it was corrected. Previous-head CI passed. - Live Daytona acceptance passed on `0b5cbb763a`: isolated real PostgreSQL, normal runtime acquisition through independent receiver processes, actual Daytona plugin/SDK 0.203.0, one disposable Ubuntu 24.04 sandbox (1 CPU / 1 GiB RAM / 1 GiB disk). A forced lease insert failure retained the committed operation; a fresh receiver with empty disk found the same sandbox, repeated recovery retained one cleanup owner, and the actual claimed cleanup sweep expired the lease and resolved the operation. Independent SDK lookup returned typed not-found; ordinary recorded-ID inspection returned destroyed. This successful attempt made one create, one recovery lookup, and one teardown. Two earlier failed harness/provider-confirmation attempts are disclosed in the [live acceptance record](https://github.com/paperclipai/paperclip/pull/18357#issuecomment-6530313054). The coordinator independently queried all three exact resource IDs through the SDK and confirmed typed not-found for each. - Complete CI-affected heartbeat/plugin warm-task suites passed 21/21 after test corrections. An unchanged workspace exposure case passed in isolation after the prior CI shard reported an unhandled readiness rejection. Complete previous-head CI and refreshed review passed. ## Risks - Deleted companies retain an explicit manual reconciliation outcome. Recovery does not retry missing credentials or insert a lease for a deleted company. - Only Daytona declares automatic creation lookup. Other uncertain providers retain `needs_reconciliation`. A missing creation name alone cannot prove that a late allocation will never appear. - Pending operations use the existing process-local signal and startup recovery model. This does not add cross-replica wake delivery or prove deployed sleep. - Legacy direct provider probes and custom-image setup use separate lifecycles. They are outside this replacement of the run-lease orphan-file fallback. The normal Test path that acquires a runtime lease is covered. - Existing orphan files still require the separate cutover inventory and settlement. This change does not delete them. - The schema change is additive. The new SQL can be reapplied. Historical SQL and journal entries are preserved; only the oldest generated snapshot is pruned. ## Model Used OpenAI `gpt-6.1-sol`, with tool use, code execution and repository review. The harness did not report the context-window size. ## Checklist - [x] I have included a thinking path that traces from project context to this change - [x] I have specified the model used (with version and capability details) - [x] I have checked ROADMAP.md and confirmed this PR does not duplicate planned core work - [x] I have searched GitHub for duplicate or related PRs and linked them above - [x] I have either (a) linked existing issues with `Fixes: #` / `Closes #` / `Refs #` OR (b) described the issue in-PR following the relevant issue template - [x] I have not referenced internal/instance-local Paperclip issues or links (only public GitHub `#NNN` / `github.com/paperclipai/paperclip` URLs) - [x] My branch name describes the change (e.g. `docs/...`, `fix/...`) and contains no internal Paperclip ticket id or instance-derived details - [x] I have run tests locally and they pass - [x] I have added or updated tests where applicable - [x] I have updated relevant documentation to reflect my changes - [x] I have considered and documented any risks above - [x] All Paperclip CI gates are green - [x] Greptile is 5/5 with no open P2s, recommendations, or follow-ups - [x] I will address all Greptile and reviewer comments before requesting merge The required branch status checks (`ci / verify`, `ci / e2e`) and all test/build jobs passed on this head. The non-required Superagent Contributor trust and Security Scan checks are still running without findings; they are not claimed as passes. No required check or branch rule is overridden. --------- Co-authored-by: Paperclip <noreply@paperclip.ing>