DottaandPaperclip
16643a6e03
## Thinking Path > - Paperclip is the open source app people use to manage AI agents for work. > - The server owns execution, Stop delivery, and usage settlement. > - A Stop can remain pending when the controller restarts. > - Recovery must reach the existing session without starting more paid work. > - Startup and budget fences currently block that cleanup, and interrupted runs leave the restart selection. > - This pull request gives exact audited Stop cleanup a shared authority check and records its real acknowledgement. > - The benefit is safe cleanup while usage debt remains honest. ## Linked Issues or Issue Description **What happened?** A pending native run-only Stop can retain an unfinished execution owner after controller loss. Its startup cancellation fence prevents recovery admission. If teardown marks the run interrupted and clears its task lock, restart selection also omits it. A recovered session can receive cancellation without the durable acknowledgement that the normal Stop request would save. **Expected behavior** Recover only the existing remote session for the audited pending Stop. Keep fresh provider work blocked, including during budget pause. Keep incomplete usage pending until a real complete receipt arrives. **Steps to reproduce** 1. Start a native run with a held reservation and an authenticated remote checkpoint. 2. Persist a run-only Stop and its startup and execution cancellation fences before acknowledgement. 3. Lose the controller. Leave the coordinator unfinished, mark the run interrupted, and clear its task lock. 4. Attempt restart recovery and observe the missing claim or cancellation admission rejection. Related work: #14733 binds caller Stop requests. #18658 handles plugin startup cleanup obligations. #18035 proposes broader accounting changes. This change repairs existing-session Stop recovery and preserves current accounting guards. ## What Changed - Add one shared check for the exact run, company, issue, pending Stop, intent audit, live recovery lease, generation, and remote reattachment disposition. - Include eligible interrupted Stop owners in restart selection. Keep generic interruptions and another task execution owner fenced. - Reuse only the original held reservation for cleanup. Keep budget pause effective for fresh, bootstrap, dead-runner, and unproven recovery work. - Apply the same cleanup authority at heartbeat runtime selection and native entry. Skip attachment staging and warm-owner retirement only for that exact cleanup. Revalidate at session publication and fail closed if the proof changed. - Send the existing Stop through the audited cancellation producer before turn submission. Close the coordinator only after acknowledgement, including system-owned run-only Stops. - Give verified cleanup a transport purpose that retains pending semantic inputs without replay, dispatch, or a semantic reply. Add an explicit Core retain-only intake mode; preserve authenticated identity, schema, digest, sequence and replay checks. Ordinary execution still requires its dispatcher. - Add PostgreSQL, native protocol, and startup-fence regressions. Update the execution contract and recovery maps. ## Verification - The combined Stop regression fails on unchanged production at the cancellation reservation guard. Interrupted restart selection also fails before the repair while its running sibling passes. - An assembled `heartbeatService.recoverNativeRunsAfterRestart` regression exposes the earlier runtime-selection fence with the rest of the repair present. The fixed path reaches selector/claim, runtime selection, original held-budget reuse during pause, dispatch, real native protocol, audited cancellation, and heartbeat settlement. It starts no provider turn, acquires no new sandbox, and does not reclaim the task lock. - Fail-if-called attachment staging and turn boundaries remain untouched. A retained warm-owner regression prevents retirement. Invalidation at session publication fails closed. Actual backend/driver constructor tests verify cleanup-purpose forwarding, absent default options, and denial under foreign ownership. - Missing usage retains accounting debt and the hold. A later complete receipt records one 25-cent charge and settles that same hold. Concurrent duplicate cleanup is denied. Both user-owned and system-owned Stops pass. - Real transport tests: 9 pass on Node 24.22.1. They preserve ordinary saved-tool and completion recovery, prove the authority-denial race before cancellation, and qualify cleanup with pending ordinary/completion inputs and either handler ordering. - Real authenticated Core intake: 11 pass. Callback-present and callback-absent retain-only cases persist and acknowledge unanswered input without dispatch, recovery or result. Default missing-dispatcher rejection and digest-integrity/suspension guards remain effective. Omitting the callback alone first failed by disconnecting; the explicit retain-only mode fixes that defect. - Repository `pnpm -r typecheck`, the server/runner-vendor build, map checks, and module boundary checks passed locally before integrating the latest retained-startup change. That integration passes 11 native startup/cleanup compatibility cases and 3 assembled recovery/accounting cases. The final broad affected-suite attempt was stopped without a verdict; it is incomplete. Full repository tests and build are delegated to current-head GitHub CI. - Review exposed an additional real-process close failure with unanswered input. The corrected path requires a fresh exact provider-stop receipt confirming exit, followed by durable event drain and exact runner suspension. All 11 focused transport cases pass, including missing/false exit-proof negatives and ordinary recovery siblings. Runner TypeScript and map validation pass after this correction. - The assembled test controls provider, workspace-transfer and GitHub bootstrap I/O. It does not qualify hosted credentials, physical provider termination, workspace preservation, or historical receipt recovery. Local socket-permission setup failures are separate from semantic regression results. No hosted replay has run on this repair. - CI exposed an ordinary factory-call compatibility regression and an obsolete authority-read test fixture. The repair preserves single-argument ordinary calls and updates the race fixture without changing its Stop assertions. The complete native executor suite now passes all 1,049 tests; the ordinary factory boundary and all five Stop-accounting cases pass. A separate local environment-default case twice exceeded its five-second wait while other work ran; its prior-head CI case passed. The same unchanged case passed an isolated diagnostic without changing its assertion or timeout; the precise contention source remains unproven. - The final fixture edit initially used the wrong overloaded promise type. CI rejected it; the annotation-only correction passes the exact `pnpm run typecheck:build-gaps` entry point locally, including server service tests and remaining workspaces. No runtime assertion changed. - Final exact head `007fd4d04a2d6338c6dc073e97ab470a277fc3d0`: required `ci / verify` and `ci / e2e`, build, typecheck and test groups pass. Greptile is 5/5 with both findings resolved. Three expected checks are skipped; the optional native check is neutral, while its final current-head comment gives 5/5 from source inspection without a checkout or test execution. The first server-shard attempt lost its self-hosted runner connection; one scoped rerun passed. Its original annotation and unavailable-log evidence are retained. ## Risks - This changes execution authority. Cleanup requires an audited, exactly bound pending Stop, an unfinished coordinator, a live remote reattachment claim, and the original held reservation. It never authorizes a replacement provider turn. - Missing checkpoint, original held reservation, termination, or usage evidence can keep cleanup or accounting pending. The repair does not manufacture acknowledgement, replies, receipts, or zero cost. - Retain-only intake is an internal trusted constructor option. It changes no agent tool permission. Ordinary callback requirements and semantic dispatch remain unchanged. - No schema, public API, provider profile, or deployment setting changes are required. ## Model Used OpenAI Codex, `gpt-6.1-sol`, Extra High reasoning, with source inspection, code execution, and regression testing. The context-window capacity is not exposed in this session. ## Checklist - [x] I have included a thinking path that traces from project context to this change - [x] I have specified the model used (with version and capability details) - [x] I have checked ROADMAP.md and confirmed this PR does not duplicate planned core work - [x] I have searched GitHub for duplicate or related PRs and linked them above - [x] I have described the issue in-PR following the bug report template - [x] I have not referenced internal/instance-local Paperclip issues or links - [x] My branch name describes the change and contains no internal ticket ID - [x] I have run affected tests locally and they pass - [x] I have added or updated tests where applicable - [x] I have updated relevant documentation to reflect my changes - [x] I have considered and documented risks - [x] All Paperclip CI gates are green - [x] Greptile is 5/5 with no open findings - [x] I will address all reviewer comments before merge --------- Co-authored-by: Paperclip <noreply@paperclip.ing>
Paperclip agent access map
This map accompanies the feature map. It records APIs, agent entry points, permission boundaries and verification for the same capability IDs. The shared contract defines the format and maintenance rules.
The chat scenario catalog uses these same IDs for human requests and expected outcomes. Its scenarios retain the access boundaries here; neither a CEO role nor a planned scenario grants board authority or establishes a working production tool binding.
Use full capability IDs when referring to access contracts outside their file:
onboarding/company means the company capability in onboarding.md in both maps.
The feature index lists feature and
capability IDs; IDs and references
explains entry-point references and stable naming.
Browse access contracts
The same-named feature recipes define navigation and capability IDs. Run
node scripts/storybook-catalog.mjs for the generated
maps/generated/agent-access-map.md index, or browse the
published feature guide.
Add or update the affected companion; there is no central registration or count.
Existing baseline source references describe the original inspection, not current verification. Record new executed evidence in the PR, issue, or CI artifact with its revision and scope. Do not refresh unrelated headers as bookkeeping.
Using an entry
Read its Policy and Gaps before selecting an agent path. Native fallback, legacy
REST/CLI, stdio MCP and a personal assistant connection can have different
authority and availability. Use a real admitted production binding; a scenario
declaration is not an installed tool. A restricted entry records current
enforcement and leaves any unresolved delegation decision visible.
For API catalog disagreements, follow the route/service authorization and record
discovery drift. For not-applicable, retain the concrete exception and local
path. Split shared business operations from client-only presentation.
Use maintain-verification-skill to reconcile changed source and both maps.
Use verify-paperclip and existing API/runner/MCP fixtures to collect the
permitted-agent and denial evidence; report blocked/not-run coverage honestly.
Run node scripts/check-maps.mjs after editing. The structural check does not
certify permissions, API catalog coverage, tool admission or live behavior.
Native REST transport
The call_api parity change reconciles affected baselines against
58e16dbddfc9c8d0cf60867f9d9847f0feda055b and the changes in this PR. Ordinary
REST operations use the same route authorization as legacy agent REST. Dedicated
tools remain optional for those operations; protocol endpoints still need their
existing clients. Board-only routes remain restricted for agent identity.
Native search_api / call_api is enabled by default, but explicit server,
company-allowlist and binding settings can narrow admission. It requires a running
authorized native run, current task assignment and execution-run binding, company
and budget authority, task privacy, and a permitted work mode. Ask and Plan retain
mutation restrictions, and runs retain their admitted JWT scope during restart
recovery even when task mode changes. A waiting
agent does not gain independent native control just because a REST route exists.
Connection-management reads support Standard, Ask and Plan; mutations require
Standard. Skill-test runs and nonstandard task-bridge keys cannot administer
connections. These gates supplement each operation's grants, resolved resource
and target scope, and responsible-user authority. See the
rollout policy
and connection authorization.
Credential-bearing replies, including company exports and their legacy alias, stay inline under a 10 MiB limit and use encrypted mutation receipts. Other saved API snapshots are limited to the issuing actor and responsible user, plus authorized administrators. Artifact uploads enforce the same access checks as downloads; private snapshots are excluded from company exports and public company logos. Explicit deliverables use the existing sharing path. Native event history, checkpoints and completion records omit API bodies while preserving receipt metadata and replay digests. Restored webhook secrets use the same encrypted receipt and inline response policy as newly created webhook secrets. Task image access requires the company boundary and the task permission; skill-test and low-trust agents do not need company-wide browsing authority. Completion replay applies the same idempotent projection to stored and expected payloads; the run-log guide describes its fields.
Sources: API client,
catalog,
native authority,
credential storage classification,
snapshot access,
and history redaction. The affected entries remain
baseline and source-only; this reconciliation does not certify every operation.
Targeted real-route proof lives in the
API integration suite,
including owned routines, skill tests, scoped secrets, proposals and private export replay.