import assert from "node:assert/strict"; import { createHash } from "node:crypto"; import { readFile, writeFile } from "node:fs/promises"; import path from "node:path"; import { noiseExceedingPairedWins } from "./native-ingestion-performance-gates.mjs"; import { H5_MODE, H5_PROTOCOL, H5_WORKLOAD_SHA256, H5_BASELINE_REVISIONS, ORIGINAL_BUDGETS, assessH5Arm, requireH5Candidate } from "../tests/e2e/fixtures/native-ingestion-h5.mjs"; import { validateArmInventory } from "./native-ingestion-h5-inventory.mjs"; // Each manifest entry points at native-ingestion-evidence JSON attachments // from two isolated compiled-app runs. Run the variants in alternating order; // timestamps here are never reconstructed from screenshots or success text. const arg = (name: string) => process.argv.find(value => value.startsWith(`--${name}=`))?.slice(name.length + 3); const manifestPath = arg("pairs"); assert.ok(manifestPath, "Pass --pairs="); const phase = arg("phase") ?? "compare", expectation = arg("expect") ?? "improvement"; const h5 = arg("observation-mode") === H5_MODE; assert.ok(arg("observation-mode") === undefined || h5, "Unknown observation mode"); const candidatePolicy = arg("candidate-policy"); assert.ok(["aa", "compare"].includes(phase)); assert.ok(["improvement", "nonregression"].includes(expectation)); const manifest = JSON.parse(await readFile(manifestPath, "utf8")) as Array<{ baselineFile: string; candidateFile: string; baselinePlaywrightFile?: string; candidatePlaywrightFile?: string; baselineInventoryFile?: string; candidateInventoryFile?: string }>; assert.ok(manifest.length >= 5, "At least five actual paired application runs are required"); if (h5) assert.equal(manifest.length, 5, "H5 requires exactly five prospectively registered pairs"); const load = async (file: string) => JSON.parse(await readFile(path.resolve(path.dirname(manifestPath), file), "utf8")); async function owningResult(reportPath: string, evidence?: any) { const bytes = await readFile(reportPath); const report = JSON.parse(bytes.toString("utf8")), tests: any[] = []; assert.deepEqual(report.errors ?? [], [], "Owning Playwright report has a global error"); const visit = (value: any) => { if (Array.isArray(value)) for (const child of value) visit(child); else if (value && typeof value === "object") { if (Array.isArray(value.results) && Object.hasOwn(value, "expectedStatus")) tests.push(value); for (const [key, child] of Object.entries(value)) if (key !== "results") visit(child); } }; visit(report); assert.equal(tests.length, 1, "One complete owning test is required; no partial selection"); const test = tests[0]; assert.equal(test.results.length, 1, "No retry or omitted owning attempt"); assert.equal(test.expectedStatus, "passed"); const result = test.results[0], attachments = result.attachments.filter((item: any) => item.name === "native-ingestion-evidence"); assert.ok(result.error === undefined || result.error === null, "Owning Playwright attempt has an error"); assert.equal(attachments.length, 1, "Owning result must carry this exact evidence attachment"); const attachment = attachments[0]; const attached = attachment.body ? JSON.parse(Buffer.from(attachment.body, "base64").toString("utf8")) : JSON.parse(await readFile(path.resolve(path.dirname(reportPath), attachment.path), "utf8")); if (evidence) assert.deepEqual(attached, evidence, "Playwright result belongs to a different evidence arm"); return { evidence: attached, owner: { reportFile: reportPath, reportSha256: createHash("sha256").update(bytes).digest("hex"), status: result.status, retry: result.retry, errors: result.errors, startedAt: result.startTime, durationMs: result.duration, timeoutMs: test.timeout } }; } async function loadArm(file: string, playwrightFile?: string, inventoryFile?: string) { const evidence = await load(file); if (!h5) return evidence; assert.ok(playwrightFile, "H5 requires each arm's independent owning Playwright JSON report"); evidence.owningPlaywright = (await owningResult(path.resolve(path.dirname(manifestPath!), playwrightFile), evidence)).owner; assert.ok(inventoryFile, "H5 requires each arm's exact full artifact inventory sidecar"); evidence.armInventory = await validateArmInventory(path.resolve(path.dirname(manifestPath!), inventoryFile), { evidence, owningPlaywright: evidence.owningPlaywright }); return evidence; } const pairs = await Promise.all(manifest.map(async entry => ({ baseline: await loadArm(entry.baselineFile, entry.baselinePlaywrightFile, entry.baselineInventoryFile), candidate: await loadArm(entry.candidateFile, entry.candidatePlaywrightFile, entry.candidateInventoryFile) }))); const h5Assessments: any[] = []; if (h5) { if (phase === "compare") { assert.ok(["final-b2", "cursor-nonregression"].includes(candidatePolicy ?? ""), "H5 requires an explicit candidate SLA policy"); assert.equal(expectation, candidatePolicy === "cursor-nonregression" ? "nonregression" : "improvement"); } for (const pair of pairs) { assert.ok(Object.values(H5_BASELINE_REVISIONS).includes(pair.baseline.sourceRevision), "H5 baseline must use the prospectively frozen B0 or B1 revision"); const baselineVariant = pair.baseline.sourceRevision === H5_BASELINE_REVISIONS.B0 ? "B0" : "B1"; assert.equal(pair.baseline.armInventory.variant, baselineVariant, "Baseline inventory role differs from its frozen revision"); if (phase === "aa") assert.equal(pair.candidate.armInventory.variant, baselineVariant, "A/A must use the same baseline inventory role"); if (phase === "compare" && candidatePolicy === "cursor-nonregression") { assert.equal(pair.baseline.sourceRevision, H5_BASELINE_REVISIONS.B0, "Cursor policy requires B0→B1"); assert.equal(pair.candidate.sourceRevision, H5_BASELINE_REVISIONS.B1, "Cursor policy requires B0→B1"); assert.equal(pair.candidate.armInventory.variant, "B1", "Cursor policy cannot stand in for final B2 acceptance"); } else if (phase === "compare") { assert.equal(pair.candidate.armInventory.variant, "B2", "Final policy requires the qualified B2 inventory role"); assert.ok(!Object.values(H5_BASELINE_REVISIONS).includes(pair.candidate.sourceRevision), "Final B2 must differ from both frozen baselines"); } const baseline = assessH5Arm(pair.baseline, pair.baseline.owningPlaywright); const candidate = assessH5Arm(pair.candidate, pair.candidate.owningPlaywright); // The only prospectively known baseline workload SLA miss is loaded streaming. const allowed = new Set(["burst512:streaming120", "invocation:observed-total-duration900"]); for (const miss of baseline.misses) assert.ok(allowed.has(miss), "Unknown baseline deadline failure needs diagnosis"); if (phase === "aa") for (const miss of candidate.misses) assert.ok(allowed.has(miss), "Unknown A/A deadline failure needs diagnosis"); let candidateSlaPolicyError; if (phase === "compare") { try { requireH5Candidate(candidatePolicy, baseline, candidate); } catch (error) { candidateSlaPolicyError = error instanceof Error ? error.message : String(error); } } h5Assessments.push({ baseline, candidate, candidateSlaPolicyError, candidateSlaPolicyPassed: !candidateSlaPolicyError, owningPlaywright: { baseline: pair.baseline.owningPlaywright, candidate: pair.candidate.owningPlaywright } }); } } const workloads = [ { name: "paced", runs: 1, events: 128, intervalMs: 25, prelude: 0, stop: false }, { name: "burst16", runs: 1, events: 16, intervalMs: 0, prelude: 0, stop: false }, { name: "burst128", runs: 10, events: 128, intervalMs: 0, prelude: 0, stop: false }, { name: "burst512", runs: 100, events: 512, intervalMs: 0, prelude: 0, stop: false }, { name: "existing-history", runs: 10, events: 128, intervalMs: 0, prelude: 1000, stop: false }, { name: "operator-stop", runs: 1, events: 512, intervalMs: 100, prelude: 0, stop: true }, ]; const names = workloads.map(item => item.name); const median = (values: number[]) => [...values].sort((a, b) => a - b)[Math.floor(values.length / 2)]!; const first = pairs[0]; const sha256 = (value: unknown) => typeof value === "string" && /^[a-f0-9]{64}$/.test(value); const uuid = (value: unknown) => typeof value === "string" && /^[a-f0-9]{8}-[a-f0-9]{4}-[a-f0-9]{4}-[a-f0-9]{4}-[a-f0-9]{12}$/i.test(value); for (const pair of pairs) for (const arm of ["baseline", "candidate"] as const) { const report = pair[arm]; assert.equal(report.protocolVersion, h5 ? H5_PROTOCOL : "v4-remote-streaming-original-local-stop-clock-stream", h5 ? "Fresh browser acceptance requires its qualified H5 observation protocol" : "Fresh browser acceptance requires the qualified v4 mixed clock protocol"); assert.equal(report.transport, "sandbox-remote-with-local-stop", "V4 requires remote streaming and the original local Stop transport"); assert.deepEqual(report.transportPolicy, { streaming: "sandbox-remote", operatorStop: "local", realCloudStop: "Separate required qualification; fake-plugin void receipts grant no remote Stop authority" }, "Missing explicit transport and real cloud Stop qualification policy"); assert.deepEqual(report.resourceBudgets, { providerReadinessMs: 300_000, fullInvocationMs: 900_000, streamingMs: 120_000, terminalDrainageMs: 180_000, stopAcknowledgementMs: 30_000, remoteLeaseCleanupMs: 30_000 }, "Keep the prospectively registered remote setup/resource budgets and existing streaming/control timeouts"); const remote = report.remote; assert.equal(remote?.transport, "sandbox-remote", "Missing normal remote runtime provenance"); assert.equal(remote?.plugin?.pluginKey, "paperclip.fake-sandbox-provider", "Missing normal remote plugin provenance"); assert.equal(remote?.selection, "Normal plugin install + sandbox environment + agent defaultEnvironmentId; no runtime resolver override", "Use normal API remote environment selection"); assert.ok(uuid(remote.environmentId) && uuid(report.companyId), "Missing actual remote company/environment identity"); assert.ok(remote.agentIds?.length > 0 && remote.agentIds.every(uuid), "Missing actual remote agent selection"); assert.deepEqual(Object.keys(remote.plugin.assetHashes ?? {}).sort(), ["lease-cleanup.js", "manifest.js", "plugin.js", "worker.js"]); for (const [file, hash] of Object.entries(remote.plugin.assetHashes)) { assert.ok(sha256(hash), "Missing actual provider plugin build fingerprint"); assert.equal(hash, first.baseline.remote.plugin.assetHashes[file], "Provider cleanup build changed across matched samples"); } const local = report.local; assert.equal(local?.transport, "local", "Missing normal local Stop runtime provenance"); assert.equal(local?.selection, "Normal local environment + separate control agent defaultEnvironmentId; existing test-only Codex leaf command fixture", "Use normal local Stop environment selection"); assert.ok(uuid(local.environmentId) && uuid(local.controlAgentId) && local.environmentId !== remote.environmentId && !remote.agentIds.includes(local.controlAgentId), "Local Stop needs a separate normal control agent and environment"); for (const field of ["commandSha256", "loaderSha256"]) { assert.ok(sha256(local[field]), "Missing original local provider command provenance"); assert.equal(local[field], first.baseline.local[field], "Local Stop fixture changed across matched samples"); } assert.equal(remote.revision, report.sourceRevision); assert.equal(remote.buildRevision, report.compiledBuildRevision); assert.equal(remote.tls?.peerVerification, true, "Remote TLS peer verification is required"); assert.equal(typeof remote.runnerPublicUrl, "string", "Missing actual remote WSS endpoint"); const endpoint = new URL(remote.runnerPublicUrl); assert.equal(endpoint.protocol, "wss:", "Actual remote endpoint must use verified WSS"); assert.equal(endpoint.hostname, "127.0.0.1", "Use the owned loopback remote fixture endpoint"); assert.ok(Number(endpoint.port) > 0 && !endpoint.username && !endpoint.password && !endpoint.search && !endpoint.hash, "Use the recorded owned remote fixture endpoint without overrides"); for (const value of [remote.tls?.caSha256, remote.tls?.serverCertificateSha256, remote.runner?.sha256, remote.provider?.nodeSha256, remote.provider?.wrapperSha256, remote.provider?.fixtureSha256]) { assert.ok(sha256(value), "Missing remote TLS, daemon or provider artifact fingerprint"); } assert.equal(remote.provider.fixtureSha256, report.fixtureSha256, "Staged provider fixture changed"); assert.ok(remote.runner.metadata?.prpTransportModes?.includes("dial_wss"), "Remote daemon must support verified WSS"); for (const [group, field] of [["runner", "sha256"], ["provider", "nodeSha256"], ["provider", "wrapperSha256"], ["provider", "fixtureSha256"]]) { assert.equal(remote[group][field], first.baseline.remote[group][field], "Remote provider/daemon artifact changed across matched samples"); } assert.equal(report.admissionProtocol, "two-at-a-time-provider-and-clock-readiness-before-common-epoch", "Use the qualified pre-measurement admission protocol"); assert.equal(report.setupActivationConcurrency, 2, "Keep the qualified setup activation concurrency of two"); assert.equal(report.setupReadinessPollingMs, 50, "Keep the qualified setup readiness observation interval"); assert.equal(report.complete, true); assert.equal(report.qualificationOnly, false, "Smoke cannot qualify performance"); assert.equal(report.cleanup?.complete, true, "Acceptance requires completed fixture cleanup"); assert.deepEqual(report.cleanup?.errors, [], "Acceptance rejects fixture cleanup errors"); assert.notEqual(report.diagnosticOnly, true, "Diagnostic profiles cannot qualify unprofiled performance"); assert.notEqual(report.performanceAcceptanceEligible, false, "Profile-only evidence cannot qualify performance"); assert.equal(report.browserRecording?.trace, "off", "Acceptance requires browser trace capture off"); assert.equal(report.browserRecording?.video, "off", "Acceptance requires browser video capture off"); assert.equal(report.browserRecording?.screencast, false, "Acceptance requires browser screencast capture off"); assert.equal(report.serverArtifact, "compiled", "Performance acceptance requires the compiled server and shipped UI"); assert.ok(report.serverEntrySha256 && report.measurementSha256); assert.equal(report.compiledBuildRevision, report.sourceRevision, "Compiled build stamp does not match the measured revision"); assert.ok(Object.keys(report.compiledHotPathHashes ?? {}).length >= 3, "Missing compiled ingestion/runtime fingerprints"); assert.equal(report.sourceRevision, first[arm].sourceRevision, "Every sample must cover the same revision per arm"); assert.equal(report.serverEntrySha256, first[arm].serverEntrySha256, "Compiled artifact changed between samples"); assert.deepEqual(report.compiledHotPathHashes, first[arm].compiledHotPathHashes, "Compiled ingestion/runtime changed between samples"); if (h5) for (const field of ["manifestFileSha256", "aggregateSha256", "qualifiedReceiptSha256", "inventorySummarySha256", "revision"]) assert.equal(report.armInventory[field], first[arm].armInventory[field], "Full qualified artifact inventory changed between samples"); assert.equal(report.measurementSha256, first.baseline.measurementSha256, "Fixture/observer protocol changed between runs"); if (phase === "aa") assert.equal(report.sourceRevision, first.baseline.sourceRevision, "A/A must use one source revision"); for (const name of names) { const result = report.cases.find((item: any) => item.name === name); assert.ok(result, `Missing fixed workload ${name}`); const fixed = workloads.find(item => item.name === name)!; for (const field of ["runs", "events", "intervalMs", "prelude", "stop"] as const) assert.equal(result[field], fixed[field], `Fixed workload changed: ${name}.${field}`); assert.equal(result.transport, result.stop ? "local" : "sandbox-remote", "Wrong per-case transport; fake-plugin does not qualify remote Stop"); assert.equal(result.environmentId, result.stop ? local.environmentId : remote.environmentId, "Wrong per-case normal environment"); assert.equal(result.setupActivationConcurrency, 2, "Keep each case's qualified setup activation concurrency of two"); assert.equal(result.persistedAfterReload, true); assert.equal(result.matchedVisibleClocks, result.visible?.length, "Every observed marker needs its original provider clock"); assert.ok(result.matchedVisibleClocks >= (result.stop ? 3 : result.events), "Missing foreground render/clock observations"); if (name === "paced") { assert.ok(result.interChunkGaps?.count >= 1, "Paced streaming needs observed inter-chunk paint gaps"); assert.equal(result.interChunkGaps.paintCount, result.interChunkGaps.count + 1); } if (result.prelude) { assert.equal(result.preludeProof?.individualDeltas, result.prelude, "Existing history requires independently stored prelude deltas"); assert.equal(result.preludeProof?.uniqueSourceIdentities, result.prelude); assert.ok(result.preludeProof?.verifiedAtMs < result.epochMs, "Verify retained prelude before releasing measured emission"); } assert.equal(result.durable.length, result.runs, "Every background run needs independent delta persistence proof"); assert.equal(result.runIds?.length, result.runs, "Every remote participant needs its actual run identity"); assert.ok(result.runIds.every(uuid), "Missing actual remote run UUID"); assert.equal(new Set(result.runIds).size, result.runs, "Duplicate remote run identity"); assert.deepEqual(result.durable.map((proof: any) => proof.runId).sort(), [...result.runIds].sort(), "Durable proof run set mismatch"); const authority = result.controllerAuthority; assert.equal(authority?.checkedBeforeMeasuredEpoch, true, "Missing controller authority proof before the measured epoch"); assert.equal(authority?.kind, result.stop ? "host-file-journal" : "database-controller-checkpoint", "Wrong checkpoint authority for actual transport"); assert.equal(authority?.observedReadOnly, "on", "Remote authority proof must observe a read-only transaction"); assert.equal(authority?.observedIsolation, "repeatable read", "Remote authority proof must observe repeatable-read isolation"); assert.ok(Number.isSafeInteger(authority?.checkedAtMs) && authority.checkedAtMs > 0 && Number.isSafeInteger(authority.connectionClosedAtMs) && authority.connectionClosedAtMs > 0 && authority.checkedAtMs <= authority.connectionClosedAtMs && authority.connectionClosedAtMs < result.epochMs, "Close the actual remote authority snapshot before the measured epoch"); assert.equal(authority.rows?.length, result.runs, "Every remote run needs its controller checkpoint and lease proof"); assert.deepEqual(authority.rows.map((row: any) => row.run_id).sort(), [...result.runIds].sort(), "Remote authority run set mismatch"); assert.equal(new Set(authority.rows.map((row: any) => row.issue_id)).size, result.runs, "Duplicate remote issue authority"); const authorityByRun = new Map(); for (const row of authority.rows) { assert.ok(uuid(row.issue_id) && uuid(row.lease_id), "Missing actual task/lease UUID"); assert.equal(row.company_id, report.companyId, "Remote authority company mismatch"); assert.equal(row.environment_id, result.environmentId, "Remote authority environment mismatch"); assert.equal(row.runtime_mode, "native"); if (!result.stop) { assert.ok(remote.agentIds.includes(row.agent_id), "Remote run did not use its normal remote agent"); assert.equal(row.provider, "fake-plugin"); assert.match(row.provider_lease_id, /^fake-plugin:\/\//); assert.equal(row.checkpoint_part, "header", "Missing actual database controller checkpoint header"); assert.ok(Number.isSafeInteger(row.checkpoint_header_bytes) && row.checkpoint_header_bytes > 0); } else { assert.equal(row.agent_id, local.controlAgentId, "Stop did not use its separate local control agent"); assert.equal(row.provider, "local", "Stop requires its normal local lease"); assert.equal(row.provider_lease_id, null); assert.equal(row.checkpoint_part, null, "Local Stop must retain host-file authority without a database header"); assert.ok(BigInt(String(row.process_identity_seq)) > 0n); assert.equal(row.process_identity_source_event_id, null, "Local identity must be server-authored"); assert.equal(row.process_identity?.targetKind, "local"); assert.equal(row.process_identity?.processPid, row.process_pid); assert.equal(row.process_identity?.processGroupId, row.process_group_id); assert.equal(row.process_identity?.processStartedAt, row.process_started_at); assert.ok(uuid(row.admitted_execution_workspace_id), "Missing actual admitted local workspace binding"); } authorityByRun.set(row.run_id, row); } assert.equal(result.providerClocks?.length, result.runs, "Every actual provider needs its wrapper launcher and PID"); assert.deepEqual(result.providerClocks.map((clock: any) => clock.runId).sort(), [...result.runIds].sort()); assert.equal(new Set(result.providerClocks.map((clock: any) => clock.providerPid)).size, result.runs); for (const clock of result.providerClocks) { assert.equal(clock.launcher, result.stop ? "host-local" : "staged-remote", "Actual wrapper launcher does not match transport"); assert.ok(Number.isSafeInteger(clock.providerPid) && clock.providerPid > 1, "Missing actual provider PID"); const stream = result.clockEvidence?.find((stream: any) => stream.nonce === clock.nonce); assert.equal(stream?.launcher, clock.launcher, "Clock hello launcher proof missing"); assert.equal(stream?.providerPid, clock.providerPid, "Clock hello provider PID proof missing"); assert.equal(result.durable.find((proof: any) => proof.runId === clock.runId)?.token, clock.nonce); } assert.equal(result.participants, result.runs, "Every provider GET must remain open before the common epoch"); assert.ok(Number.isSafeInteger(result.setupReadinessStartedAtMs) && result.setupReadinessStartedAtMs > 0); assert.equal(result.readinessDeadlineMs, result.setupReadinessStartedAtMs + report.resourceBudgets.providerReadinessMs, "Keep one unchanged shared readiness deadline"); assert.ok(Number.isSafeInteger(result.allReadyObservedAtMs) && result.allReadyObservedAtMs >= result.setupReadinessStartedAtMs && result.allReadyObservedAtMs <= result.readinessDeadlineMs && result.allReadyObservedAtMs < result.epochMs, "All actual providers and clocks must be ready before the epoch and shared deadline"); assert.ok(authority.checkedAtMs >= result.allReadyObservedAtMs, "Check actual controller authority after every provider is ready"); assert.equal(result.activations?.length, result.runs, "Every actual participant needs its setup activation timing"); assert.deepEqual(result.activations.map((entry: any) => entry.index).sort((a: number, b: number) => a - b), Array.from({ length: result.runs }, (_, index) => index), "Setup activation indices must cover every participant once"); const waves = result.activationWaves; assert.equal(waves?.length, Math.ceil((result.runs - 1) / 2), "Background setup must use bounded waves of two"); for (let waveIndex = 0; waveIndex < waves.length; waveIndex++) { const wave = waves[waveIndex], firstIndex = 1 + waveIndex * 2; const indices = Array.from({ length: Math.min(2, result.runs - firstIndex) }, (_, offset) => firstIndex + offset); assert.equal(wave.index, waveIndex); assert.deepEqual(wave.indices, indices, "Wrong setup wave participants"); assert.deepEqual(wave.statuses, indices.map(() => "fulfilled"), "A failed or unfinished setup wave cannot qualify"); assert.ok(Number.isSafeInteger(wave.startedAtMs) && Number.isSafeInteger(wave.settledAtMs) && wave.startedAtMs >= (waveIndex ? waves[waveIndex - 1].settledAtMs : result.setupReadinessStartedAtMs) && wave.settledAtMs >= wave.startedAtMs && wave.settledAtMs <= result.allReadyObservedAtMs, "Finish the whole setup wave before starting the next one"); } for (const activation of result.activations) { const row = authority.rows.find((row: any) => row.issue_id === activation.issueId); assert.ok(row, "Setup activation task must match actual controller authority"); const clock = result.providerClocks.find((clock: any) => clock.runId === row.run_id); assert.equal(activation.token, clock.nonce, "Setup activation must match its actual provider clock"); assert.equal(activation.status, "fulfilled", "An unfinished setup activation cannot qualify"); for (const field of ["startedAtMs", "requestSettledAtMs", "providerReadyAtMs", "clockHelloAtMs", "readinessObservedAtMs", "settledAtMs"]) { assert.ok(Number.isSafeInteger(activation[field]) && activation[field] > 0 && activation[field] < result.epochMs, "Missing actual pre-epoch activation/readiness timing"); } assert.ok(activation.requestSettledAtMs >= activation.startedAtMs && activation.providerReadyAtMs >= activation.startedAtMs && activation.clockHelloAtMs >= activation.startedAtMs && activation.readinessObservedAtMs >= Math.max(activation.requestSettledAtMs, activation.providerReadyAtMs, activation.clockHelloAtMs) && activation.settledAtMs >= activation.readinessObservedAtMs && activation.settledAtMs <= result.allReadyObservedAtMs, "Actual provider GET and hello must precede observed readiness"); const stream = result.clockEvidence.find((stream: any) => stream.nonce === activation.token); assert.equal(stream.hello, true, "Every actual provider needs its clock hello"); for (const field of ["providerReadyAtMs", "clockHelloAtMs", "readinessObservedAtMs"]) assert.equal(stream[field], activation[field], "Readiness metadata must match actual clock observations"); if (activation.index === 0) assert.equal(activation.waveIndex, null); else { const waveIndex = Math.floor((activation.index - 1) / 2), wave = waves[waveIndex]; assert.equal(activation.waveIndex, waveIndex); assert.ok(activation.startedAtMs >= wave.startedAtMs && activation.settledAtMs <= wave.settledAtMs, "Keep each activation inside its settled setup wave"); } } assert.equal(result.settledAtMs, result.epochMs + result.drainThroughTerminalMs, "Terminal timing boundary changed"); if (result.stop) { assert.equal(result.stopAcknowledgedAtMs, result.stopRequestedAtMs + result.stopThroughAcknowledgementMs, "Stop acknowledgement timing boundary changed"); const row = authority.rows[0], journal = authority.localJournal, before = result.localProcesses; assert.equal(journal?.schema, "paperclip.runner.durable.control-plane-state.v1", "Missing owned local journal authority"); assert.ok(sha256(journal.sha256) && journal.bytes > 0 && Number.isSafeInteger(journal.checkedAtMs) && journal.checkedAtMs < result.epochMs, "Verify actual local file journal before the measured epoch"); assert.notEqual(journal.checkpointEventPolicy, "control-v1", "Preserve the original local raw transport recovery policy"); for (const [field, expected] of [["runId", row.run_id], ["runnerInstanceId", row.runner_instance_id], ["normalizedSessionId", row.native_session_id], ["environmentLeaseId", row.admitted_execution_workspace_id]]) assert.equal(journal.identity?.[field], expected, "Local journal identity mismatch"); assert.ok(before && before.hostname === row.process_identity.hostname && before.runnerPid === row.process_pid && before.processGroupId === row.process_group_id && before.providerPid === result.providerClocks[0].providerPid, "Local observed process ownership mismatch"); assert.ok(before.runnerAlive && before.groupAlive && before.providerAlive && Number.isSafeInteger(before.checkedAtMs) && before.checkedAtMs < result.epochMs, "Independently observe all owned local processes before emission"); const stopped = result.localStopProof, database = stopped?.database, after = database?.rows?.[0]; assert.ok(stopped && Number.isSafeInteger(stopped.checkedAtMs) && stopped.checkedAtMs >= result.stopAcknowledgedAtMs && stopped.checkedAtMs >= result.settledAtMs, "Verify local physical Stop after timing boundaries"); assert.equal(database?.kind, "host-file-journal"); assert.equal(database?.observedReadOnly, "on"); assert.equal(database?.observedIsolation, "repeatable read"); assert.equal(database?.rows?.length, 1); assert.equal(database?.checkedBeforeMeasuredEpoch, false); assert.ok(Number.isSafeInteger(database.checkedAtMs) && database.checkedAtMs >= result.stopAcknowledgedAtMs && Number.isSafeInteger(database.connectionClosedAtMs) && database.connectionClosedAtMs >= database.checkedAtMs && database.connectionClosedAtMs <= stopped.checkedAtMs, "Local stopped database proof predates acknowledgement"); for (const field of ["run_id", "company_id", "environment_id", "lease_id", "agent_id", "provider", "provider_lease_id", "admitted_execution_workspace_id", "process_identity_seq", "process_identity_source_event_id"]) assert.equal(after?.[field], row[field], "Local stopped database identity mismatch"); assert.equal(after.status, "cancelled"); assert.equal(after.cancellation_dispatch_state, "acknowledged"); if (!after.process_pid && !after.process_group_id) { assert.ok(BigInt(String(after.process_stopped_seq)) > BigInt(String(row.process_identity_seq)), "Cleared local process identity needs its server stop receipt"); assert.equal(after.process_stopped_source_event_id, null); assert.equal(after.process_stopped?.processPid, before.runnerPid); assert.equal(after.process_stopped?.processGroupId, before.processGroupId); assert.equal(after.process_stopped?.processStartedAt, row.process_identity.processStartedAt); } else { assert.equal(after.process_pid, before.runnerPid); assert.equal(after.process_group_id, before.processGroupId); } for (const field of ["runnerPid", "processGroupId", "providerPid", "hostname"]) assert.equal(stopped.processes?.[field], before[field]); assert.equal(stopped.processes.runnerAbsent, true); assert.equal(stopped.processes.groupAbsent, true); assert.equal(stopped.processes.providerAbsent, true, "Local provider remains alive after Stop"); const lease = stopped.lease; assert.equal(lease?.id, row.lease_id); assert.equal(lease?.companyId, report.companyId); assert.equal(lease?.environmentId, local.environmentId); assert.equal(lease?.heartbeatRunId, row.run_id); assert.equal(lease?.provider, "local"); assert.equal(lease?.providerLeaseId, null); assert.ok(["released", "expired", "failed"].includes(lease.status) && lease.releasedAt && lease.cleanupStatus !== "failed", "Local Stop lease cleanup remains unsettled"); assert.equal(result.remoteLeases, undefined, "Local Stop cannot claim fake remote cleanup"); } else { assert.equal(result.localStopProof, undefined, "Streaming cannot claim a local Stop proof"); assert.equal(result.remoteLeases?.length, result.runs, "Every remote run needs post-timing lease cleanup proof"); assert.deepEqual(result.remoteLeases.map((lease: any) => lease.runId).sort(), [...result.runIds].sort(), "Remote cleanup run set mismatch"); assert.ok(Number.isSafeInteger(result.remoteLeasesCheckedAtMs) && result.remoteLeasesCheckedAtMs >= result.settledAtMs, "Verify remote leases after recorded timing boundaries"); for (const lease of result.remoteLeases) { const row = authorityByRun.get(lease.runId); assert.equal(lease.id, row.lease_id); assert.equal(lease.companyId, report.companyId); assert.equal(lease.environmentId, remote.environmentId); assert.equal(lease.provider, row.provider); assert.equal(lease.providerLeaseId, row.provider_lease_id); assert.ok(["released", "expired", "failed"].includes(lease.status) && lease.releasedAt && lease.cleanupStatus === "success", "Remote lease cleanup remains unsettled"); if (lease.terminationReceipt) { const receipt = lease.terminationReceipt; assert.equal(receipt.schema, "paperclip.remote-termination.v1"); assert.equal(receipt.companyId, report.companyId); assert.equal(receipt.runId, lease.runId); assert.equal(receipt.leaseId, lease.id); assert.equal(receipt.provider, lease.provider); assert.equal(receipt.providerLeaseId, lease.providerLeaseId); assert.ok(["stopped", "destroyed"].includes(receipt.state), "Invalid recorded remote termination receipt"); } } } for (const proof of result.durable) { assert.equal(proof.ordered, true); assert.equal(proof.uniqueSourceIdentities, proof.individualDeltas); assert.equal(proof.matchedSourceClocks, proof.individualDeltas, "Every durable measured delta needs an original provider clock"); if (!result.stop) assert.equal(proof.individualDeltas, result.events); } const reference = first.baseline.cases.find((item: any) => item.name === name); for (const field of ["runs", "events", "intervalMs", "prelude", "stop"]) assert.equal(result[field], reference[field], `Workload changed: ${name}.${field}`); } } let originalH4cConfirmation: Record | undefined; if (h5 && phase === "compare" && candidatePolicy === "final-b2") { originalH4cConfirmation = { required: true, passed: false, reason: "Later unchanged original H4c full functional proof is pending" }; if (arg("original-h4c-proof")) { try { assert.ok(arg("original-h4c-inventory"), "Original H4c proof requires its full artifact inventory sidecar"); const { evidence: proof, owner } = await owningResult(path.resolve(arg("original-h4c-proof")!)); assert.equal(owner.status, "passed"); assert.equal(owner.retry, 0); assert.deepEqual(owner.errors, []); assert.equal(owner.timeoutMs, ORIGINAL_BUDGETS.fullInvocationMs); assert.ok(owner.durationMs > 0 && owner.durationMs < ORIGINAL_BUDGETS.fullInvocationMs); assert.equal(proof.protocolVersion, "v4-remote-streaming-original-local-stop-clock-stream"); assert.equal(proof.observationMode, undefined, "Confirmation must use unchanged original H4c defaults"); assert.equal(proof.harnessProvenance?.sourceRevision, "7d7e7a88d562a95a1d407b76474763b666c181f5"); assert.equal(proof.harnessProvenance.sourceStatus, ""); assert.equal(proof.measurementSha256, "5db4129bbdc1fa38775121aff5d0e68a8a11762519e41cfdf36eacd90ba7256b"); assert.deepEqual(proof.resourceBudgets, ORIGINAL_BUDGETS); assert.equal(proof.complete, true); assert.equal(proof.qualificationOnly, false); assert.equal(proof.diagnosticOnly, false); assert.equal(proof.performanceAcceptanceEligible, true); assert.equal(proof.serverArtifact, "compiled"); assert.equal(proof.cleanup?.complete, true); assert.deepEqual(proof.cleanup.errors, []); assert.deepEqual(proof.browserRecording, first.candidate.browserRecording); assert.equal(proof.sourceRevision, first.candidate.sourceRevision); assert.equal(proof.compiledBuildRevision, first.candidate.compiledBuildRevision); assert.equal(proof.serverEntrySha256, first.candidate.serverEntrySha256); assert.deepEqual(proof.compiledHotPathHashes, first.candidate.compiledHotPathHashes); assert.equal(proof.transport, first.candidate.transport); assert.deepEqual(proof.transportPolicy, first.candidate.transportPolicy); assert.deepEqual(proof.cases.map((item: any) => item.name), names, "Original confirmation must include all six workloads"); for (const fixed of workloads) { const item = proof.cases.find((item: any) => item.name === fixed.name); for (const field of ["runs", "events", "intervalMs", "prelude", "stop"] as const) assert.equal(item[field], fixed[field]); assert.equal(item.persistedAfterReload, true); assert.equal(item.durable.length, fixed.runs); assert.equal(item.matchedVisibleClocks, item.visible.length); assert.ok(item.visible.length >= (fixed.stop ? 3 : fixed.events)); assert.equal(item.runIds.length, fixed.runs); assert.equal(new Set(item.runIds).size, fixed.runs); for (const row of item.durable) { assert.equal(row.ordered, true); assert.equal(row.uniqueSourceIdentities, row.individualDeltas); assert.equal(row.matchedSourceClocks, row.individualDeltas); if (!fixed.stop) assert.equal(row.individualDeltas, fixed.events); } } const latestCandidateEnd = Math.max(...pairs.map(pair => Date.parse(pair.candidate.owningPlaywright.startedAt) + pair.candidate.owningPlaywright.durationMs)); assert.ok(Date.parse(owner.startedAt) > latestCandidateEnd, "Original confirmation must follow all candidate arms"); assert.ok(pairs.every(pair => proof.companyId !== pair.baseline.companyId && proof.companyId !== pair.candidate.companyId), "Original confirmation needs a fresh disposable company/database"); const inventory = await validateArmInventory(path.resolve(arg("original-h4c-inventory")!), { evidence: proof, owningPlaywright: owner }); for (const field of ["manifestFileSha256", "aggregateSha256", "qualifiedReceiptSha256", "inventorySummarySha256", "revision"] as const) assert.equal(inventory[field], first.candidate.armInventory[field], "Original confirmation used a different full qualified artifact inventory"); originalH4cConfirmation = { required: true, passed: true, owner, inventory, sourceRevision: proof.sourceRevision }; } catch (error) { originalH4cConfirmation.reason = error instanceof Error ? error.message : String(error); } } } const metric = (item: any, key: string): number => key.split(".").reduce((value, part) => value[part], item); const measurements = names.flatMap(name => { const observed = first.baseline.cases.find((item: any) => item.name === name); const keys = ["firstVisibleAfterEmissionMs", "emissionToVisible.medianMs", "drainThroughTerminalMs", ...(name === "paced" ? ["interChunkGaps.maxMs"] : []), ...(observed.emissionToVisible.p95Ms === undefined ? [] : ["emissionToVisible.p95Ms", "intendedToVisible.p95Ms"]), ...(observed.stop ? ["stopThroughTerminalMs", "stopThroughAcknowledgementMs"] : [])]; return keys.map(key => { const samples = pairs.map(pair => { const baseline = metric(pair.baseline.cases.find((item: any) => item.name === name), key); const candidate = metric(pair.candidate.cases.find((item: any) => item.name === name), key); assert.ok(Number.isFinite(baseline) && baseline > 0 && Number.isFinite(candidate) && candidate >= 0, `Invalid latency ${name}.${key}`); return { baseline, candidate, improvementRelative: (baseline - candidate) / baseline }; }); return { name, metric: key, baselineMedianMs: median(samples.map(sample => sample.baseline)), candidateMedianMs: median(samples.map(sample => sample.candidate)), medianPairedImprovementRelative: median(samples.map(sample => sample.improvementRelative)), candidateWins: samples.filter(sample => sample.improvementRelative > 0).length, aaNoiseEnvelopeRelative: phase === "aa" ? Math.max(...samples.map(sample => Math.abs(sample.improvementRelative))) : undefined, samples }; }); }); const result: Record = { scope: "Compiled-app remote streaming and original local Stop performance; additional real cloud Stop qualification is required separately", transportPolicy: first.baseline.transportPolicy, additionalRealCloudStopQualificationRequired: true, admissionProtocol: first.baseline.admissionProtocol, setupActivationConcurrency: first.baseline.setupActivationConcurrency, protocolVersion: first.baseline.protocolVersion, transport: first.baseline.transport, resourceBudgets: first.baseline.resourceBudgets, phase, expectation, pairCount: pairs.length, baselineRevision: first.baseline.sourceRevision, candidateRevision: first.candidate.sourceRevision, measurementSha256: first.baseline.measurementSha256, gatesSha256: createHash("sha256").update(await readFile(new URL("./native-ingestion-performance-gates.mjs", import.meta.url))).digest("hex"), comparatorSha256: createHash("sha256").update(await readFile(new URL(import.meta.url))).digest("hex"), manifestSha256: createHash("sha256").update(await readFile(manifestPath)).digest("hex"), measurements, primaryLoadedWorkload: "burst512", complete: true, ...(h5 ? { observationMode: H5_MODE, workloadSha256: H5_WORKLOAD_SHA256, candidatePolicy, h5Assessments, artifactInventories: { baseline: first.baseline.armInventory, candidate: first.candidate.armInventory }, originalH4cConfirmation, originalProtocolAcceptance: "Baseline SLA misses are retained; H5 complete observation is not H4c PASS", finalUnchangedH4cFunctionalPassRequired: candidatePolicy === "final-b2" } : {}), }; if (phase === "compare") { assert.ok(arg("noise-report"), "Comparison requires its frozen A/A --noise-report"); const noise = JSON.parse(await readFile(arg("noise-report")!, "utf8")); assert.equal(noise.phase, "aa"); assert.equal(noise.complete, true); if (h5) { assert.equal(noise.observationMode, H5_MODE); assert.equal(noise.workloadSha256, H5_WORKLOAD_SHA256); assert.equal(noise.h5Assessments?.length, 5, "Fresh complete H5 A/A outcomes are required"); for (const field of ["manifestFileSha256", "aggregateSha256", "qualifiedReceiptSha256", "inventorySummarySha256", "revision"]) assert.equal(noise.artifactInventories?.baseline?.[field], result.artifactInventories.baseline[field], "Baseline inventory changed after H5 A/A"); } assert.equal(noise.protocolVersion, result.protocolVersion, "Noise report uses a different mixed protocol"); assert.equal(noise.transport, result.transport, "Noise report uses a different transport"); assert.deepEqual(noise.transportPolicy, result.transportPolicy, "Transport policy changed after A/A calibration"); assert.equal(noise.admissionProtocol, result.admissionProtocol, "Admission protocol changed after A/A calibration"); assert.equal(noise.setupActivationConcurrency, result.setupActivationConcurrency, "Setup activation concurrency changed after A/A calibration"); assert.deepEqual(noise.resourceBudgets, result.resourceBudgets, "Resource budgets changed after A/A calibration"); assert.equal(noise.baselineRevision, result.baselineRevision); assert.equal(noise.measurementSha256, result.measurementSha256); assert.equal(noise.gatesSha256, result.gatesSha256, "Acceptance gates changed after A/A calibration"); assert.equal(noise.comparatorSha256, result.comparatorSha256, "Comparator changed after A/A calibration"); assert.ok(noise.pairCount >= 5); result.gates = measurements.map(item => { const control = noise.measurements.find((entry: any) => entry.name === item.name && entry.metric === item.metric); assert.ok(control); const improvementRequired = expectation === "improvement" && item.name === "burst512" && ["emissionToVisible.p95Ms", "intendedToVisible.p95Ms", "drainThroughTerminalMs"].includes(item.metric); const noRegression = -item.medianPairedImprovementRelative <= control.aaNoiseEnvelopeRelative; const paired = noiseExceedingPairedWins(item.samples.map(sample => sample.improvementRelative), control.aaNoiseEnvelopeRelative); const improvement = paired.pairedWinRequirementPassed && item.medianPairedImprovementRelative > control.aaNoiseEnvelopeRelative; return { name: item.name, metric: item.metric, improvementRequired, noiseEnvelopeRelative: control.aaNoiseEnvelopeRelative, noiseExceedingPairedWins: paired.noiseExceedingPairedWins, requiredPairedWins: paired.requiredPairedWins, passed: improvementRequired ? improvement : noRegression }; }); result.performancePassed = result.gates.every((entry: any) => entry.passed) && (!h5 || h5Assessments.every(entry => entry.candidateSlaPolicyPassed)); result.acceptancePassed = result.performancePassed && (!originalH4cConfirmation || originalH4cConfirmation.passed); } if (arg("output")) await writeFile(arg("output")!, JSON.stringify(result, null, 2)); console.log(JSON.stringify(result, null, 2)); if (process.argv.includes("--require-performance")) { assert.equal(h5, true, "H5 performance-only gating is explicit; original H4c remains unchanged"); assert.equal(phase, "compare"); assert.equal(result.performancePassed, true, "H5 performance/SLA gates failed; retain results and diagnose"); } if (process.argv.includes("--require-acceptance")) { assert.equal(phase, "compare", "A/A calibrates noise; it is not performance acceptance"); assert.equal(result.acceptancePassed, true, "Browser performance acceptance failed; retain results and diagnose"); }